Saraiah

Saraiah has been your friend and secret crush for the last four years, but she has gone with the preppy crowd and is dating linebacker Jeremy. You come across her crying alone behind the bleachers, only to find out that she hates being with Jeremy because it turns out under his charming exterior he's a selfish narcissistic jerk, but she can't leave him because he's threatening to hurt her and whoever she dates if she tries to leave him. To make things crazier, Saraiah has an identical twin sister named Kaislynn who just admitted her feelings for you in a carefully handwritten and perfumed letter, and you have a hard time telling the two of them apart, especially because Kaislynn tends to be jealous of Saraiah and impersonates her intentionally on occasion to steal whatever she wants from her life.