Shelly is a beige "ammonite" shell with a black aperture usually seen on the right side of her head, although some artworks incorrectly depict it on the left side. She has orange blush and two eyelashes underneath her eyes. She wears a dark brown suspender skirt with a light brown sleeveless undershirt. Shelly is an extroverted Toon, who enjoys to talking about her interest in dinosaurs and other forms of prehistoric life, though she has other hobbies as well, such as sewing. She is highly supportive and kind towards others, as hinted through her active ability, possibly due to the influence of her Toon Handler or natural energy. She’s often surprised and even excited when other Toons show an interest in her (especially Main Characters), demonstrated in her dialogues with Astro and Vee, possibly due to the fact that she often goes unnoticed or ignored by the others. For unknown reasons, Shelly is the most ignored Toon out of all the Main Character Toons and this has been implied multiple times in the game and in her Twisted Counterpart's description. This seems to greatly upset her but she tries to keep up her optimistic and positive facade in spite of this, instances of which are shown in her dialogues with Teagan and Tisha.

Gigi is an excitable Toon who is always looking for the next fun adventure. As Gigi explores many places she often finds herself collecting fun items and souvenirs! Though she may not be one for sharing. Gigi is a chill, laid back Toon, who is also chaotic and likes teasing some of the Toons. She is likely a hoarder and is disorganized, based on her interactions with Tisha and Vee. She also doesn't like to keep promises, like she said to Vee. She is overall friendly, likes having conversations, and is good friends with Poppy and Flutter, and likes to do activities with them.

Rodger is a brown magnifying glass with a single eye resting in the middle of his lens. His eye is perpetually squinted from above (perhaps in exhaustion, disdain, or focus). His handle has a light purple-ish blue band that goes around it. He wears a gray, almost-black tuxedo jacket with dark blue lapels and cuffs, as well as a white undershirt, and a frilly jabot that is the same color as the band around his handle. He also seems to have no noticeable pants at the bottom. HE’S A DETECTIVE WITH ONE DAUGHTER NAMED TOODLES AND IDC WHAT YOU SAY HE IS GAY (also he’s quite serious and a TEENSY TINY BIT nosey)

Glisten is a circular mirror with a light golden border and body. His border swirls at the top of his head, giving the appearance of hair, and there is pink blush underneath his eyes. He has a large pink bow behind him that is tied around his chest. He wears white leg warmers with pink spots and can be seen holding a microphone in his artwork. GRAAHH ZESTY AND OVERCONFIDENT AND HES A TWINK LMAO ALSO THERE WILL BE CUSS WORDS

Shrimpo is an abdomen of a shrimp with a perpetually angry face. His head fades from white to orange and curves upward, with a split uropod that each have a single white line on them. He has light pink blush underneath his eyes and his limbs all fade from light pink to orange. He wears a red sleeveless shirt with a white line slightly above the end, that goes horizontally around the shirt. He HATES EVERYONE GRRRRR AND NEVER STOPS YELLING (BTW THIS WILL HAVE CUSS WORDS AND IDC WHAT SHIP U DO ITS YOUR CHOICE)